Luxon says India will face different FTA immigration settings, but denies discrimination

New Zealand 4 min read

Prime minister Christopher Luxon and immigration minister Erica Stanford.

"It’s very normal that the minister of immigration imposes bespoke conditions on any FTA visas."

Ravi Bajpai July 7, 2026

Prime minister Christopher Luxon says immigration settings linked to New Zealand’s free trade agreement with India will be different from those in agreements with other countries, but has rejected claims the approach is discriminatory.

Speaking to RNZ’s Morning Report on Monday, Luxon defended the government’s handling of immigration settings attached to the India deal after foreign minister Winston Peters accused National of covertly making immigration changes that would discriminate against Indians migrating to New Zealand.

Peters said he had a document showing immigration minister Erica Stanford had approved changes that officials warned would be “more restrictive in a way which targets India and India alone”.

He said the proposed changes could affect relations with India and New Zealand’s reputation.

Luxon told Morning Report the approach was not discriminatory and said the India agreement would have different immigration settings from deals with other countries.

“Every deal is different,” he said.

“Different access is negotiated, and in this case, as there is with all of them, there’s a new visa negotiated under a new FTA.”

Luxon said it was normal for the immigration minister to impose conditions specific to visas negotiated through trade agreements.

“It’s very normal that the minister of immigration imposes bespoke conditions on any FTA visas that are negotiated, quite normal.”

He said the government was following usual cabinet processes.

“It’s set within the confines of our government to determine all of that, and we deliver on those FTA commitments that we’ve made, so that’s exactly what we’re doing here.”

The comments come after Stanford said last week that “initial decisions consistent with the FTA have been sent to other ministers for feedback, prior to immigration instructions being finalised”.

She also said the government had “always been clear that immigration settings are specific to each free trade agreement”.

“As is standard practice Immigration New Zealand is preparing for implementation, subject to final decisions being made,” Stanford said.

The debate comes as a parliamentary committee has separately concluded that New Zealand’s immigration commitments under the India FTA are “relatively narrow” and do not open migration floodgates.

Luxon said both India and New Zealand were happy with the deal and accused Peters of playing politics over an agreement he remained staunchly opposed to.

“I think it’s very easy to indulge in some anti-immigration politics, and the reality is, this is a country that has legal immigration,” Luxon said.

“I get it’s easy politics, it’s just wrong.”

Luxon also questioned Peters’ position on Indian migration.

“On the one hand, he said few weeks back, oh we’ve got way too many Indians coming into the country, and now we’re saying we haven’t got enough.”

The political dispute comes against a wider debate over the tone of the FTA contest, with concern previously raised across ACT and the Greens that rhetoric and misinformation around the agreement could fuel anti-Indian sentiment.

The coalition row widened again on Monday as ACT leader David Seymour criticised another part of the deal.

Seymour lashed out at trade minister Todd McClay over a line in the agreement affirming New Zealand and India’s respective positions on the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.

He said the provision was one of several “fish hooks” unrelated to trade in recent FTAs and claimed the UNDRIP clause had been “snuck into” the India deal.

“The government of India didn’t want it, the government of New Zealand didn’t want it, but the bureaucracy put it in there,” Seymour said.

“We relied on Todd McClay to say that we’re not doing any extraneous stuff around the Treaty in this free trade agreement, he assured us we weren’t, and it turns out we were.”

Seymour said he supported proceeding with the agreement.

“I just say rock on with the free trade agreement, but make sure ... the next trade minister is capable of ensuring it’s just a free trade agreement, not someone else’s political project or a vehicle for it.”

Labour trade spokesperson Damien O’Connor accused both New Zealand First and ACT of disloyalty.

“David Seymour, like Winston Peters, is just making politics of an agreement that has huge potential,” he said.

“On balance, Labour believes it’s worth signing. It’s not perfect, but for them to play politics is simply disloyal to our country.”

Labour has already confirmed it will support the India-New Zealand FTA through Parliament, while ACT also backs the deal and New Zealand First has refused to support it.

The dispute is unfolding days before Indian prime minister Narendra Modi arrives in New Zealand, with his Auckland-only programme scheduled for July 10 and 11.

Papatoetoe poll: Police close case with no charges, after most Indian candidates win re-run

Papatoetoe poll: Police close case with no charges, after most Indian candidates win re-run

Months after the Indian-origin ticket won the re-election, police now say they can't prove any electoral fraud.

Aug 21, 2026 | 3 min read
$52,000 per person: How a Tauranga labour hire company sold jobs for cash in India

$52,000 per person: How a Tauranga labour hire company sold jobs for cash in India

An Employment Relations Authority ruling lays bare the transnational exchange of cash for visas in the horticulture industry.

Aug 21, 2026 | 5 min read
Why India did a trade deal with New Zealand. Explained by its foreign minister’s son

Why India did a trade deal with New Zealand. Explained by its foreign minister’s son

"In this day and age, we can't completely separate economics and strategy," public policy expert Dhruva Jaishankar says.

Aug 21, 2026 | 9 min read
'Ethnic makeup' doesn't spook Winston Peters. 'Societal makeup' is the concern, he says

'Ethnic makeup' doesn't spook Winston Peters. 'Societal makeup' is the concern, he says

“The whole dichotomy of New Zealand society is changing without any consent of the New Zealand people.”

Aug 20, 2026 | 5 min read
Election 2026: Can New Zealand please start talking about creating wealth?

Election 2026: Can New Zealand please start talking about creating wealth?

Socialism and capitalism are often presented as an ideological argument. History shows us no economic system is a magic solution.

Aug 20, 2026 | 4 min read
Woman denied freedom to choose husband in India granted asylum in New Zealand

Woman denied freedom to choose husband in India granted asylum in New Zealand

In recognising her as a refugee, the immigration tribunal has identified the relevant protected social group simply as "women".

Aug 19, 2026 | 4 min read
‘Not enough demand’: Education ministry pours cold water on push for Hindi as school subject

‘Not enough demand’: Education ministry pours cold water on push for Hindi as school subject

A parliamentary committee is reviewing a petition to formalise Hindi as part of New Zealand's education framework.

Aug 19, 2026 | 5 min read
Disloyalty cost Penk his job. How come Peters gets away with racism? Hipkins asks

Disloyalty cost Penk his job. How come Peters gets away with racism? Hipkins asks

The Opposition leader is asking why Luxon hasn't shown similar appetite for consequences over racist remarks.

Aug 18, 2026 | 4 min read
Kiwi-Indian millionaire who joined Luxon’s India delegation is leaving New Zealand

Kiwi-Indian millionaire who joined Luxon’s India delegation is leaving New Zealand

Kaur’s departure is particularly striking because she is almost exactly the sort of success story New Zealand has been keen to celebrate.

Aug 18, 2026 | 4 min read
After months attacking the India FTA, Peters has suddenly stopped talking about it

After months attacking the India FTA, Peters has suddenly stopped talking about it

The trade deal has disappeared almost completely from the NZ First leader's election speeches lately.

Aug 18, 2026 | 5 min read
Recommended article

Crime & Justice

Woman denied freedom to choose husband in India granted asylum in New Zealand

Policy & Governance

A former National candidate wants MPs drug-tested four times a year. Not just for the obvious

Politics

Peters' 'go back' culture-war is beginning to bite NZ First and dent its popularity

Policy & Governance

Diaspora members hide names, switch off cameras amid rising foreign interference fears

Recommended article

Policy & Governance

The Parent Resident Visa queue is back. The door is still narrow.