Exploited migrant won nearly $150,000, was offered $600. She’s still fighting for a dollar

New Zealand 5 min read
Exploited migrant won nearly $150,000, was offered $600. She’s still fighting for a dollar

The woman arrived in New Zealand in 2018.

Two former employers are in liquidation and their director is bankrupt, leaving a Rotorua woman facing an uncertain future.

Ravi Bajpai November 19, 2026

On February 1, 2022, Arushi had got the news from immigration officials. They had approved her residence. Later that day, at the Rotorua tavern where she worked, she became caught in a confrontation that would cost her the job she had paid thousands of dollars to keep.

The customer, she said, had made racist remarks. Arushi asked how he would feel if she called him “white trash”. Her employer later fired her for serious misconduct.

When she challenged the dismissal, the case exposed years of underpayment and two unlawful $10,000 job fees. Her father had borrowed money in India to help pay the first. For the second, she borrowed from friends and deposited the money into her boss’s bank account, determined to leave a record.

Arushi won. The employment tribunal orders in her favour eventually totalled nearly $150,000 before interest. Her former employers came back with another offer. They were diversifying their business and could pay only $600.

Now both companies are in liquidation, their director Kulvinder Singh is bankrupt, and their challenge to Arushi's win is before the Employment Court.

In a November 16 order, judge Kathryn Beck gave Singh until February 27, 2027, to deposit $48,635.50 with the court to cover potential legal bills for Arushi. If he fails to pay, the challenge will be dismissed.

The companies and Singh had originally been ordered to make that deposit by February 27 this year. They never paid it, leaving the challenge on hold while Arushi continued to incur legal bills.

A job with a price

Arushi, who is originally from India, secured a duty manager’s role at Rotorua’s VC Turf Bar in July 2018 on a one-year work visa.

She told the Employment Relations Authority (ERA) that a few days later, Singh demanded $10,000, saying it related to her visa and taxes he was paying on her behalf. She said he threatened to arrange for her visa to be cancelled if she did not pay.

Her father told the authority he borrowed money from friends and a market moneylender. He and other family members then visited a contact in Chandigarh and handed over the equivalent of $10,000 in cash.

Singh denied requesting or receiving the payment. But tribunal member Sarah Blick found it was more probable than not that the money had been demanded and paid as an unlawful fee connected to Arushi’s employment.

In April 2019, Arushi was promoted to general manager at another Rotorua tavern, operated by Isher Enterprises. Singh was a director of both Isher and Lionmead Capital Group, which ran VC Turf Bar.

Her evidence before the tribunal also described an arrangement in which the pay rate on her employment agreement differed from what she would receive.

The agreement stated $26 an hour to meet immigration requirements, she said, but she and Singh had discussed that she would actually be paid $20.

She applied for residence under the Skilled Migrant Category in July 2019 and received a further three-year work visa that August.

Arushi said Singh demanded another $10,000 in January 2020. She delayed paying, but said the pressure became too much.

That November, she combined her savings with money borrowed from two friends. This time, she deposited the $10,000 directly into Singh’s personal bank account so there would be a record.

Singh acknowledged receiving the money but said it concerned repayment of a loan involving a mutual friend. Blick found it was another unlawful job fee.

Arushi also kept diaries recording her hours. She said she often worked 55 to 60 hours over six days but was told to record only 40. The companies disputed her records. The authority ultimately ordered them to repay more than $61,000 in wages and holiday pay.

The confrontation

Arushi’s residence was approved under the 2021 Residence Visa on February 1, 2022. The same day, she went to work and became involved in a dispute with a regular customer over an order of takeaway food.

She said another female employee returned from his table visibly upset after he made inappropriate comments. Arushi took his food over herself and told him he could not speak to staff that way.

What followed was disputed. Arushi said he made racist remarks and refused to leave, and acknowledged asking how he would feel if she called him “white trash”.

Isher dismissed her the following month. But Blick found the employer’s investigation was flawed and its conclusion that Arushi had bullied the customer was unreasonable.

Arushi told the authority she was anxious about finding another hospitality job during the pandemic. Border closures had kept her husband from joining her until mid-2022, leaving her largely on her own while dealing with the employment dispute.

Blick awarded her $30,000 for humiliation, loss of dignity and emotional harm arising from the dismissal. A further $4,000 recognised the financial and emotional distress caused by underpayment.

Winning and recovering

In her October 3, 2024 order, Blick ordered payments to Arushi totalling $119,980.82 before interest. That included repayment of the two job fees, wage and holiday pay arrears, compensation and her share of financial penalties.

Each company was penalised $8,000 for failing to provide wage and time records when requested. Arushi was awarded $4,800 of those penalties, with the remaining $11,200 payable to the Crown.

When her lawyers sought payment, the companies said they could collectively put $600 towards the outstanding amount. They said their businesses were developing and they hoped to increase payments as their finances improved.

Arushi rejected the proposal. On November 29, Blick ordered the companies and Singh to pay another $28,318.20 towards her legal bills, application fee and hearing fees, bringing her total award to $148,299 before interest.

By then, the companies and Singh had already challenged the original ruling in the Employment Court. Before the ERA, they had denied Arushi’s claims, accused her of fabricating allegations and records, and maintained her dismissal was justified.

Both companies went into liquidation on March 12, 2026. Singh was declared bankrupt on July 28.

The ERA had given Arushi permission to recover the job fees, unpaid wages, holiday pay and interest from Singh personally if the companies could not pay. His bankruptcy now puts that recovery through another insolvency process.

Arushi asked the Employment Court to dismiss the challenge because the companies and Singh had failed to move it forward. Beck’s latest ruling gives Singh until February to pay the court deposit.

For Arushi, even the dismissal of that challenge would leave another question. How much money is available to repay her.