'Pretty crass': Luxon slams Shane Jones as hypocritcal over Modi jibe, India FTA comments

New Zealand 3 min read

Prime minister Christopher Luxon and India's Narendra Modi.

"I'm actually proud of the team and all the efforts that went into hosting a significant world leader in Prime Minister Modi."

RNZ Morning Report July 20, 2026

The prime minister says comments made by New Zealand First's deputy leader about the free trade agreement (FTA) with India were "crass and unprofessional", saying his coalition partner is on the wrong side of history.

At NZFirst's annual convention over the weekend, deputy leader Shane Jones criticised supporters of the deal, saying his party was "nationalist" and was speaking up for New Zealanders' interests.

NZ First does not support the deal, citing concerns over immigration and whether the clause to promote investment of $34 billion is actually a firm investment commitment with repercussions if New Zealand fails to reach that target.

Jones said he would "call out" the levels of Indian migration into New Zealand "every day, every week, every month".

"It is not foundational Kiwi culture to have foreigners running slave gangs in our kiwifruit industry, never paying tax, owing more to the IRD than the GDP of Kaitaia. Put them on the first plane and send them home."

Referring to the visit of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi the weekend prior, Jones then addressed the leaders of other parties.

"Labour Party, National Party, ACT Party, Green Party: the next time you go to an ethno-nationalist rally to receive a foreign leader, take off your knee pads. You represent the New Zealand Parliament."

Asked about Jones' comments on Morning Report, Christopher Luxon said he remained proud of the deal.

"Pretty crass and unprofessional comments. I'm actually super proud of our India FTA, I'm actually proud of the team and all the efforts that went into hosting a significant world leader in Prime Minister Modi, and I would have thought that we actually want all of New Zealand presenting well out on the global stage."

Similarly to comments made by ACT last week, Luxon pointed out the irony of NZ First opposing the deal while one of its ministers visited India to promote New Zealand wool.

"Frankly, it's a bit hypocritical from NZ First to be against the Indian FTA while they've got their colleague, the Associate Agriculture Minister Mark Patterson, out there in India trying to sell tariff-free New Zealand wool under the FTA to Indians.

"So at least he realises the massive economic benefits of the FTA for the people in the regions."

'I don't talk about your poll' - Luxon dismisses polling slump

Luxon was also asked about the latest RNZ-Reid Research poll result, which put National on its lowest result since he became leader.

National was at 28.7 percent, a fall of 2.1 percentage points and its fourth consecutive decline in this poll.

But Luxon dismissed the result, saying there were lots of polls and his focus was on fixing the "gnarly, hard problems" facing the country.

"I don't talk about your poll. What I can tell you is, though, that even just having come back from the States, is I reckon the US, Australia, places like that are on an economic downswing. I think New Zealand's on an economic upswing.

"We see that 14 percent growth in Kiwis coming back home from Australia last year. We've got good economic growth. You saw manufacturing expanding last week, services expanding, good levels of exports, investor-farmer confidence, and business confidence actually on the improve.

"It's been a difficult two years, no doubt about it. But New Zealand's certainly on an upswing, and that's my job is to drive it home."

This story was first published on rnz.co.nz

Recommended article

Policy & Governance

The Parent Resident Visa queue is back. The door is still narrow.

Policy & Governance

Modi preparing for maiden visit to New Zealand, alongside trip to Australia in July

Crime & Justice

Holi overstayers update: Delhi organiser blames "fraudulent agent", fuels visa scam doubts

Crime & Justice

Kiwi-Indian robbed thrice in 10 months tells parliament committee why retailers need more powers

Policy & Governance

Out Loud: Tightening deportation rules and the limits of being a migrant

Recommended article

Community

Kia Ora Modi: Luxon to depart from official programme to attend Auckland community event

More stories

1

Gone in 4 years: Wealthy migrants, including Indians, are leaving New Zealand

2

Khalistan, asylum and bad faith: What NZ's new immigration bill really changes

3

Heartbroken Sikh man who found Islam at an Auckland market gets asylum

4

'Moment of integrity': Calls for Indian diaspora to pitch in after Holi overstayers fiasco

Most Popular

Analysis: Police review of Rakesh Naidoo’s Labour move finds the problem wasn’t Naidoo

Analysis: Police review of Rakesh Naidoo’s Labour move finds the problem wasn’t Naidoo

An internal review has found the senior police officer's conduct in the days leading up to his big political reveal seems quite kosher.

Aug 13, 2026 | 8 min read
The Parent Resident Visa queue is back. The door is still narrow.

The Parent Resident Visa queue is back. The door is still narrow.

There is an obvious problem with having to wait up to five years. Circumstances change.

Aug 13, 2026 | 8 min read
Christopher Luxon's leadership victory: You come at the King, you best not miss

Christopher Luxon's leadership victory: You come at the King, you best not miss

It's a bold call to punish his opponents, and a bit of a farce when he's only gone after one.

Aug 13, 2026 | 8 min read
NZ First says population trends are at a ‘crisis point’. The reality is not that simple

NZ First says population trends are at a ‘crisis point’. The reality is not that simple

A policy predicated on increasing the number of 'certain babies' is neither effective nor necessary.

Aug 12, 2026 | 8 min read
MPs want limits on immigration officers’ power to demand ID after racial profiling concerns

MPs want limits on immigration officers’ power to demand ID after racial profiling concerns

Critics argue under the new provisions appearance, accent or perceived migrant status could influence who seemed suspicious.

Aug 12, 2026 | 8 min read
The Luxon dilemma: Should he stay or should he go?

The Luxon dilemma: Should he stay or should he go?

Luxon's personal performance has had moments of reprieve but that was all undone last week.

Aug 11, 2026 | 8 min read
Māori or not, everyone will have to take New Zealand’s new citizenship test

Māori or not, everyone will have to take New Zealand’s new citizenship test

The government clarification comes amid a wider debate about preferential citizenship rights for people with Maori ancestry.

Aug 11, 2026 | 8 min read
‘One day, I’m going to...’: The Kiwi-Indian family behind Air NZ’s famous lollies

‘One day, I’m going to...’: The Kiwi-Indian family behind Air NZ’s famous lollies

The Bhikha family now makes 22 million of Air New Zealand’s famous lollies each year.

Aug 11, 2026 | 8 min read
MPs bin ACT's election policy to make some migrants liable for deportation for life

MPs bin ACT's election policy to make some migrants liable for deportation for life

ACT Party's proposal would raise questions of proportionality in criminal justice, a select committee has found.

Aug 10, 2026 | 8 min read
Coalition leadership is hard. But Luxon’s ‘nuclear option’ of dumping MMP is not the answer

Coalition leadership is hard. But Luxon’s ‘nuclear option’ of dumping MMP is not the answer

Casting the country back to an electoral system that delivered disproportionate power won't address the real problem.

Aug 10, 2026 | 8 min read